Playwright vs. Selenium: Choosing a Headless Browser for Effective Web Scraping

In web automation, two key players often come up: Playwright and Selenium. Both are robust automation testing tools, yet they fulfill different needs and have distinct advantages. This article compares Playwright vs. Selenium features, diving into the main differences and benefits.

Playwright

Playwright, created by Microsoft, is a cutting-edge automation tool explicitly crafted for web applications. Released in 2020, it aims to provide a smooth experience with features that are in tune with the latest web technologies. 

Playwright allows developers to write tests that can run across multiple browsers, making it ideal for testing complex applications.

Selenium

Selenium has been a cornerstone in web automation since the early 2000s. As an open-source framework, it supports a wide range of browsers and programming languages. It is popular for its flexibility and strong community support, making it a go-to choice for developers.

Playwright vs. Selenium Comparison

Browser Support

Playwright supports three major browsers: Chromium, Firefox, and WebKit. This allows developers to test their applications across different environments with minimal setup. 

In contrast, Selenium offers broader browser support, including Chrome, Firefox, Safari, Edge, and even older versions like Internet Explorer. 

If your project requires testing on legacy systems or a wider variety of browsers, Selenium might be the better choice.

Language Support

Playwright supports JavaScript, Python, C#, and Java programming languages, making it accessible to teams familiar with these languages. 

Selenium supports a wider range of languages, including Java, Python, C#, Ruby, and JavaScript. Therefore, if you work with multiple programming languages or have existing codebases in these languages, Selenium could be more suitable.

Performance

Playwright generally outperforms Selenium due to its modern architecture and features like auto-waiting. This allows Playwright to execute tests faster and more efficiently without requiring manual waits for elements to load. 

Conversely, Selenium may be slower depending on the setup and configuration.

Auto-Waiting Mechanism

A standout feature of Playwright is its auto-waiting capability; it automatically waits for elements to be ready before performing actions. This reduces the need for developers to manually implement wait conditions in their tests. 

In contrast, Selenium does not have this feature built-in. However, developers can use Selenium’s methods to set waits manually.

Debugging Tools

Playwright offers advanced debugging capabilities, including taking screenshots and recording videos during test runs, which makes it easier to identify issues when they arise. 

Selenium provides basic debugging tools but often relies on external solutions for more comprehensive debugging.

Parallel Testing

Parallel testing is crucial for speeding up execution times in large projects. Playwright natively supports parallel testing out of the box without complex configurations. 

However, Selenium needs additional configuration to conduct parallel tests using Selenium Grid.

Headless Mode

Both tools support headless mode (running tests without a graphical user interface (GUI)), which is beneficial for running tests in environments where a GUI is not available or desired (like CI/CD pipelines). 

However, Playwright enables headless mode by default, simplifying the setup process compared to Selenium.

Mobile Testing Support

Playwright supports mobile testing through browser contexts that simulate mobile devices directly within its framework, while Selenium requires integration with Appium or similar tools.

When deciding between Playwright and Selenium for your testing needs, it’s essential to consider the specific requirements of your project. Here’s a guide to help you determine when to use each tool:

Playwright vs. Selenium: Differences in Coding

Here are the coding differences when using Playwright vs. Selenium for scraping.

Installation

To install Playwright, follow these two steps:

• First, install the Playwright package.

Copypip install playwright

• Next, install the Playwright browser.

Copyplaywright install

Selenium can be installed with a single command:

Copypip install selenium

Importing

Playwright offers two APIs: one for synchronous execution and another for asynchronous execution. You can import either one:

Copyfrom playwright.sync_api() import sync_playwright()
# or
from playwright.async_api() import async_playwright()

For basic web scraping, Selenium requires only two modules.

• The webdriver module to control the browser:

Copyfrom selenium import webdriver

• The By module to locate elements:

Copyfrom selenium.webdriver.common.by import By

Launching the browser

Both Playwright and Selenium can be launched in headless (no GUI) and headful (with GUI) modes. However, Playwright defaults to headless mode, and you need to specify an argument to launch it in a headful mode.

Copywith sync_playwright() as p:
	#headless mode
	browser = p.chromium.launch()

	#headful mode
	browser = p.chromium.launch(headless=false)

In contrast, Selenium defaults to headful mode, requiring you to add options launch it in headless mode.

Copy#headful mode
browser = webdriver.Chrome()

#headless mode
options = webdriver.ChromeOptions()
options.add_argument(‘--headless’)

browser = webdriver.Chrome(options=options)

Note: The above code uses the methods Chrome() and ChromeOptions() because it launches a Chrome browser; the methods change with the browser. 

Navigating to a URL

In Playwright, you must create a page before navigating to a URL.

Copypage = browser.new_page()
page.goto(‘https://sample.url’)

Selenium allows you to navigate to a website with a single line of code.

Copybrowser.get(‘https://sample.url’)

While the additional code in Playwright may seem complex, it enables easier management of multiple pages. Selenium can also manage multiple pages in Selenium, but it is significantly more complicated than Playwright’s approach.

Selecting Elements

Playwright provides two main methods for selecting elements.

• Query Selector Method:

Copy# select the first element that matches the CSS selector

element = page.query_selector(‘h2’)

## select all the elements that matches the CSS selector

elements = page.query_selector_all(‘li.span’)

#selecting the element in this way allows you to get the text inside it.

text = element.inner_text()

• Locator Method:

Copy# locate the element
element = page.locator(“text=Submit”)

#Locating the element in this way allows you to perform actions on the element
element.click()

In Selenium, you can use the find_element() and find_elements() method to select elements.

Copy#select a single element using find_element()
element = browser.find_element(‘h2’)

#select a multiple elements using find_elements()
elements = browser.find_elements(‘li.span’)

Once you’ve selected an element, you can perform various operations such as:

• Extracting text

Copyelement.text

• Clicking on it

Copyelement.click()

When to Use Playwright

Consider using Playwright when you need to:

• Handle modern web applications and complex scenarios.
• Ensure consistent browser behavior as it uses a single API across browsers, unlike Selenium.
• Utilize advanced debugging features, like video recording and detailed tracing, without needing external libraries.
• Easily integrate into CI/CD  pipelines without additional plugins.
• Achieve faster performance through direct communication with the browser’s DevTools protocol, avoiding the WebDriver layer that Selenium uses. 

When to Use Selenium

Choose Selenium if you need to:

• Test across a broader range of browsers, like Opera, not supported by Playwright.
• Use a wider range of programming languages such as Kotlin and Ruby, which are not supported by Playright.
• Integrate with legacy systems 
• Benefit from a larger community for support compared to Playwright.

Why Use a Web Scraping Service?

The choice between Playwright and Selenium ultimately comes down to your project’s specific requirements. If fast execution with modern capabilities is essential, Playwright is an excellent options. However, if extensive browser compatibility or legacy system integration is required, Selenium remains a dependable choice option.

However, if data is your only concern, why trouble yourself with deciding whether to use Playwright or Selenium? You can use a web scraping service, like ScrapeHero, to get the data you need. 

ScrapeHero is a fully managed web scraping service capable of building enterprise-grade web scrapers and crawlers. Tell us your data requirements, and we will deliver the data. 

FAQs